People who are unfamiliar with Lyme disease, and the medical and political controversy that now surrounds it, frequently ask the question, "How could this possibly be?" In the spirit of a-picture's-worth-a-thousand-words, this column will be uncharacteristically brief. The following video is courtesy of the renowned Dr. Joe Jemsek, of the Jemsek Specialty Clinic. Dr. Jemsek is speaking at the Into the Light, Lyme Disease Awareness Gala, which was held in March 2009. Enjoy.
Ok, just a few comments... ;-) to add a Canadian context. How does this American tragedy affect us on this side of the border? Well, you take Health Canada's bogus statistics for Lyme disease and our seriously flawed Lyme tests. Then add the IDSA's 2006 Lyme treatment guidelines, which declares Chronic Lyme disease to be all in our heads. Add to that the CDC announcement that Lyme is an "emerging epidemic" in the US. What do you get? At best, you get a confused Canadian medical system that's faced with some conflicting input. At its worst, you get Canada's regulatory Medical Colleges declaring war on the handful of Canadian doctors actively involved with treating Lyme disease -- and the Colleges are not answerable to anyone for their obscene actions.
At least 3 cases of heavy-handed actions by Medical Colleges have been publicized to date. First was the now late Dr. Philip Williams, whose treatment of Lyme disease was restricted by the CPSO in 2004. Then in early 2008, the CPSBC forced Canada's Lyme disease guru, Dr. Ernie Murakami, into retirement with the threat of removing his licence. Most recently, Dr. Jozef Krop had the files of 20 of his Lyme patients seized by CPSO investigators in October 2008 -- that investigation is ongoing in spite of the fact there had not been one patient complaint against him. Sound like the sort of environment that will encourage doctors to seriously consider Lyme disease in their differential diagnosis?
Monday, July 20, 2009
Lyme disease established in New Brunswick
More Lyme in the news. This piece aired on CBC New Brunswick on July 15, 2009.
In the northern Saint John community of Millidgeville, an established breeding population of ticks was identified last spring. That means higher numbers of younger nymph ticks will be present -- about the size of a poppy seed, they are much harder to see than adult ticks, but capable of carrying and transmitting Lyme disease.
Limited surveillance has revealed that 20% of the Millidgeville-area ticks are positive carriers of the Lyme bacteria. That's twice the supposed national average of 10%. Such limited surveillance has been done throughout our country, with most of that being passive surveillance (when ticks are voluntarily submitted by veterinarians and doctors for analysis), it's difficult to put much credence in these numbers -- passive surveillance will, at the best of times, tend to significantly underestimate the real numbers. The reality is, in spite of our health authorities' continuing characterization of Lyme as a new and emerging illness in Canada, everywhere they look they are finding it! Ask the patients that have been misdiagnosed and battling this illness for decades -- this disease has long been present in every province of our country.
And it's all well and good that continued efforts go into studying tick populations (a similar study to the one in Millidgeville is taking place this summer in the Wainfleet Bog area of the Niagara Peninsula of Ontario). But when will action be taken to improve the quality of Lyme testing available to Canadians? According to the handful of Lyme-literate physicians across the country, Canada's Lyme tests are not worth the paper they are printed on. Very few Lyme patients test positive with Canada's Lyme tests -- most are forced to pay out-of-pocket for tests from specialized tick-borne illness labs in the US. Early detection and treatment is absolutely critical in successfully treating this potentially devastating illness -- that early detection is next to impossible right now in Canada. Delayed diagnosis greatly increases the chance of developing serious chronic illness.
When will action be taken to ensure the safety of Canada's blood supply? Canada is one of the few western nations that does not currently screen its blood supply for Lyme disease! Several published studies have demonstrated the ability of Lyme bacteria to survive in treated blood products for up to 48 days.
When will action be taken to better train our doctors, so that patients are not faced with the all-too-frequent "we don't have Lyme disease here"? This happened in a southern Ontario community just a few weeks ago! And that was in spite of a Public Health Advisory about Lyme disease issued a few months prior in the same region. Our doctors are our first line of defence -- and those defences are currently down!
When will action be taken to provide meaningful public awareness? The public continues to be largely unaware of the risks for Lyme disease. While truckloads of money went into publicity campaigns for West Nile Virus -- a disease that impacts in the order of 1,000 people a year in North America -- next to nothing has been done to raise awareness of Lyme disease. The CDC now estimates in excess of 200,000 new cases of Lyme disease annually. And do you know where the vast majority of those cases are? In close proximity to the borders of Manitoba, Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia!
So the numbers in this news report suggest that 1 in 10 ticks in our country are carrying Lyme bacteria. The list of known endemic areas continues to increase in length. The recent Canadian Medical Association Journal article clearly documents the presence of ticks throughout the country. And yet Health Canada continues to report bogus numbers of only about 50 cases of Lyme a year in Canada. But of course those numbers are based on Canada's bogus tests. There are thousands of Lyme patients across the country that are not counted in Canada's stats for Lyme because their Canadian tests were negative. When will Health Canada give its collective head a shake? When will our medical community get past these numbers? -- treat the patients, not the labs.
If you or someone you know has been on the Great Canadian Lyme Adventure, please make sure your elected representatives know about it. Write to your local paper. Write your Minister of Health. The status quo is simply not good enough. Something's gotta change.
Ten days and counting...
In the northern Saint John community of Millidgeville, an established breeding population of ticks was identified last spring. That means higher numbers of younger nymph ticks will be present -- about the size of a poppy seed, they are much harder to see than adult ticks, but capable of carrying and transmitting Lyme disease.
Limited surveillance has revealed that 20% of the Millidgeville-area ticks are positive carriers of the Lyme bacteria. That's twice the supposed national average of 10%. Such limited surveillance has been done throughout our country, with most of that being passive surveillance (when ticks are voluntarily submitted by veterinarians and doctors for analysis), it's difficult to put much credence in these numbers -- passive surveillance will, at the best of times, tend to significantly underestimate the real numbers. The reality is, in spite of our health authorities' continuing characterization of Lyme as a new and emerging illness in Canada, everywhere they look they are finding it! Ask the patients that have been misdiagnosed and battling this illness for decades -- this disease has long been present in every province of our country.
And it's all well and good that continued efforts go into studying tick populations (a similar study to the one in Millidgeville is taking place this summer in the Wainfleet Bog area of the Niagara Peninsula of Ontario). But when will action be taken to improve the quality of Lyme testing available to Canadians? According to the handful of Lyme-literate physicians across the country, Canada's Lyme tests are not worth the paper they are printed on. Very few Lyme patients test positive with Canada's Lyme tests -- most are forced to pay out-of-pocket for tests from specialized tick-borne illness labs in the US. Early detection and treatment is absolutely critical in successfully treating this potentially devastating illness -- that early detection is next to impossible right now in Canada. Delayed diagnosis greatly increases the chance of developing serious chronic illness.
When will action be taken to ensure the safety of Canada's blood supply? Canada is one of the few western nations that does not currently screen its blood supply for Lyme disease! Several published studies have demonstrated the ability of Lyme bacteria to survive in treated blood products for up to 48 days.
When will action be taken to better train our doctors, so that patients are not faced with the all-too-frequent "we don't have Lyme disease here"? This happened in a southern Ontario community just a few weeks ago! And that was in spite of a Public Health Advisory about Lyme disease issued a few months prior in the same region. Our doctors are our first line of defence -- and those defences are currently down!
When will action be taken to provide meaningful public awareness? The public continues to be largely unaware of the risks for Lyme disease. While truckloads of money went into publicity campaigns for West Nile Virus -- a disease that impacts in the order of 1,000 people a year in North America -- next to nothing has been done to raise awareness of Lyme disease. The CDC now estimates in excess of 200,000 new cases of Lyme disease annually. And do you know where the vast majority of those cases are? In close proximity to the borders of Manitoba, Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia!
So the numbers in this news report suggest that 1 in 10 ticks in our country are carrying Lyme bacteria. The list of known endemic areas continues to increase in length. The recent Canadian Medical Association Journal article clearly documents the presence of ticks throughout the country. And yet Health Canada continues to report bogus numbers of only about 50 cases of Lyme a year in Canada. But of course those numbers are based on Canada's bogus tests. There are thousands of Lyme patients across the country that are not counted in Canada's stats for Lyme because their Canadian tests were negative. When will Health Canada give its collective head a shake? When will our medical community get past these numbers? -- treat the patients, not the labs.
If you or someone you know has been on the Great Canadian Lyme Adventure, please make sure your elected representatives know about it. Write to your local paper. Write your Minister of Health. The status quo is simply not good enough. Something's gotta change.
Ten days and counting...
Monday, June 22, 2009
Cor Blimey, Guv'nor!
CT Governor signs Lyme doctor protection Bill into law.
On Sunday amidst little fanfare, Connecticut Governor M. Jodi Rell signed Bill HB6200 into law. Earlier this year the Bill received unanimous support from the Health Committee, which introduced it to the House. This was followed, with but minor revisions along the way, by the unanimous support of both Houses of the Connecticut General Assembly. It will now come into effect next month on July 1, 2009.
In what we hope will be a strong message to the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), which continues in its heavy-handed attempt to shut down the conversation surrounding Chronic Lyme, this Bill clearly comes down on side of patients, their freedom to choose treatment, and doctors' freedom to exercise their clinical judgement.
To illustrate the IDSA's persistent attitude on this subject, check out this recent exchange printed in the British Journal of Medical Ethics (JME). A few months ago, a piece appeared titled "Attorney General forces Infectious Diseases Society of America to redo Lyme guidelines due to flawed development process", in which Johnson and Stricker outlined the reasons why the IDSA now finds itself in the position of having to review its 2006 Lyme disease guidelines with a completely new panel. In May 2009, IDSA President Anne Gershon submitted a reply to the JME in which she continues the Society's spin (you know the drill, but to paraphrase: Chronic Lyme doesn't exist, long-term antibiotic treatment is ineffective and dangerous). It is quite astonishing that she would put such statements in writing given that the guidelines review process is still in progress! Or are we to surmise from her comments that the outcome of that review has already been determined...? Well, the responses to President Gershon posted by the JME were not pretty (quite good reading, but not pretty).
This is the very stuff that got IDSA into trouble in the first place. The 2008 post-investigation press release from the Connecticut Attorney General's office states it clearly: The IDSA's 2000 and 2006 Lyme disease panels refused to accept or meaningfully consider information regarding the existence of chronic Lyme disease, once removing a panelist from the 2000 panel who dissented from the group's position on chronic Lyme disease to achieve "consensus". Let's hope this is not déjà vu all over again. Time will tell.
Mark this date on your calendar: July 30, 2009. That's the date of the IDSA's "open" public hearing in Washington, DC (you know... the open public hearing that the public cannot actually attend). The IDSA has promised to broadcast that hearing live via their website.
While some have attempted to misrepresent Connecticut's new Bill as an ill-advised attempt to "legislate medicine", it is quite the contrary -- it does not tell doctors what they have to do (unlike the IDSA guidelines), but rather protects their freedom to use their judgement without undue interference from regulatory bodies. Governor Rell had this to say about the Bill: “Doctors in Connecticut – the absolute epicenter of Lyme disease – can continue to do what is best for their patients suffering from this complex illness. I think most people know someone who has been infected. The bill also recognizes that Lyme disease patients must have the freedom to choose which remedy or regimen best meets their needs.”
Here is the press release from the Lyme Disease Association, and brief coverage from HersamAcorn.com.
Please let your elected representatives know about this exciting development in Connecticut, which now follows similar legislation in California and Rhode Island, in addition to the non-legislative approach implemented by New York. Canada's Lyme doctors continue to be harassed by our medical colleges. Many doctors will not treat Lyme patients for fear their licence could be in jeopardy. This needs to stop.
Three cheers for Guv'nor Rell!
On Sunday amidst little fanfare, Connecticut Governor M. Jodi Rell signed Bill HB6200 into law. Earlier this year the Bill received unanimous support from the Health Committee, which introduced it to the House. This was followed, with but minor revisions along the way, by the unanimous support of both Houses of the Connecticut General Assembly. It will now come into effect next month on July 1, 2009.
In what we hope will be a strong message to the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), which continues in its heavy-handed attempt to shut down the conversation surrounding Chronic Lyme, this Bill clearly comes down on side of patients, their freedom to choose treatment, and doctors' freedom to exercise their clinical judgement.
To illustrate the IDSA's persistent attitude on this subject, check out this recent exchange printed in the British Journal of Medical Ethics (JME). A few months ago, a piece appeared titled "Attorney General forces Infectious Diseases Society of America to redo Lyme guidelines due to flawed development process", in which Johnson and Stricker outlined the reasons why the IDSA now finds itself in the position of having to review its 2006 Lyme disease guidelines with a completely new panel. In May 2009, IDSA President Anne Gershon submitted a reply to the JME in which she continues the Society's spin (you know the drill, but to paraphrase: Chronic Lyme doesn't exist, long-term antibiotic treatment is ineffective and dangerous). It is quite astonishing that she would put such statements in writing given that the guidelines review process is still in progress! Or are we to surmise from her comments that the outcome of that review has already been determined...? Well, the responses to President Gershon posted by the JME were not pretty (quite good reading, but not pretty).
This is the very stuff that got IDSA into trouble in the first place. The 2008 post-investigation press release from the Connecticut Attorney General's office states it clearly: The IDSA's 2000 and 2006 Lyme disease panels refused to accept or meaningfully consider information regarding the existence of chronic Lyme disease, once removing a panelist from the 2000 panel who dissented from the group's position on chronic Lyme disease to achieve "consensus". Let's hope this is not déjà vu all over again. Time will tell.
Mark this date on your calendar: July 30, 2009. That's the date of the IDSA's "open" public hearing in Washington, DC (you know... the open public hearing that the public cannot actually attend). The IDSA has promised to broadcast that hearing live via their website.
While some have attempted to misrepresent Connecticut's new Bill as an ill-advised attempt to "legislate medicine", it is quite the contrary -- it does not tell doctors what they have to do (unlike the IDSA guidelines), but rather protects their freedom to use their judgement without undue interference from regulatory bodies. Governor Rell had this to say about the Bill: “Doctors in Connecticut – the absolute epicenter of Lyme disease – can continue to do what is best for their patients suffering from this complex illness. I think most people know someone who has been infected. The bill also recognizes that Lyme disease patients must have the freedom to choose which remedy or regimen best meets their needs.”
Here is the press release from the Lyme Disease Association, and brief coverage from HersamAcorn.com.
Please let your elected representatives know about this exciting development in Connecticut, which now follows similar legislation in California and Rhode Island, in addition to the non-legislative approach implemented by New York. Canada's Lyme doctors continue to be harassed by our medical colleges. Many doctors will not treat Lyme patients for fear their licence could be in jeopardy. This needs to stop.
Three cheers for Guv'nor Rell!
Monday, June 8, 2009
Tracking Lyme disease in Canada
CTV News: Avis Favaro covers the rise of this infectious disease.
"Lyme disease is moving its way into new parts of Canada but the government is not doing enough to track it or to teach doctors how to diagnose it, says a new report."
"The painful and debilitating affliction known as Lyme disease is spreading in Canada and with the summer outdoor season about to get into full swing, doctors are being asked to report even suspected cases to help health officials track it."
For the compete article visit CTV.ca online. A video report, which aired Monday June 8, 2009 on CTV National News can be viewed here.
A related piece by the CBC is titled Lyme disease spreading in Canada, researchers find. Here are links to a CBC video report in Real Media and QuickTime formats.
A report this week in the Canadian Medical Association Journal titled The emergence of Lyme disease in Canada outlines the increase in Lyme endemic areas across our country. While there is really nothing new here from the perspective of the Lyme community (there have been Lyme patients suffering in every province of the country for years), it is nice to see some acknowledgement of the problem from medical officials.
Please ask your elected officials what will be done to teach our doctors how to diagnose this debilitating disease.
"Lyme disease is moving its way into new parts of Canada but the government is not doing enough to track it or to teach doctors how to diagnose it, says a new report.""The painful and debilitating affliction known as Lyme disease is spreading in Canada and with the summer outdoor season about to get into full swing, doctors are being asked to report even suspected cases to help health officials track it."
For the compete article visit CTV.ca online. A video report, which aired Monday June 8, 2009 on CTV National News can be viewed here.
A related piece by the CBC is titled Lyme disease spreading in Canada, researchers find. Here are links to a CBC video report in Real Media and QuickTime formats.
A report this week in the Canadian Medical Association Journal titled The emergence of Lyme disease in Canada outlines the increase in Lyme endemic areas across our country. While there is really nothing new here from the perspective of the Lyme community (there have been Lyme patients suffering in every province of the country for years), it is nice to see some acknowledgement of the problem from medical officials.
Please ask your elected officials what will be done to teach our doctors how to diagnose this debilitating disease.
Saturday, May 30, 2009
Lyme Action in Elora
Elora rocks!
Lyme Action Group, together with the Lyme Disease Association of Ontario, participated in the Sustainable Futures Aware Fair in Elora today, an event to raise awareness about environmental issues and human rights, and the link between them.
Sharing our booth with Habitat for Humanity and right next door to the enticing aroma of Planet Bean's fair trade coffee, we were in good company. It was a great day and fortunately the rain held off!
Thank you to everyone who visited our booth, and signed our Ontario Legislature Chronic Lyme disease petition. Your support is much appreciated.
Compliments to the students of Centre Wellington District High School for your great work in organizing this event!
Sharing our booth with Habitat for Humanity and right next door to the enticing aroma of Planet Bean's fair trade coffee, we were in good company. It was a great day and fortunately the rain held off!
Thank you to everyone who visited our booth, and signed our Ontario Legislature Chronic Lyme disease petition. Your support is much appreciated.
Compliments to the students of Centre Wellington District High School for your great work in organizing this event!
Lyme is the law in CT
It's official folks -- after unanimous approval from the Health Committee, followed by unanimous approval from the House of Representatives just a month ago, yesterday the Connecticut State Senate gave unanimous approval to a Lyme bill that offers protection to that state's doctors who diagnose and treat Chronic Lyme patients. The 36 to 0 decision makes Connecticut the third state to adopt Lyme doctor protection legislation, following in the footsteps of California and Rhode Island (in addition to New York, which implemented a non-legislative solution).
An excerpt from the Lyme Disease Association press release follows:
HB 6200 contains language that will protect CT licensed Lyme treating physicians from prosecution by the State of Connecticut Medical Examining Board solely on the basis of a clinical diagnosis and /or for treatment of long-term Lyme disease. The bill provides the definition for Lyme disease which includes “the presence in a patient of signs and symptoms compatible with acute infection with Borrelia burgdorferi; or with late stage or persistent or chronic infection with Borrelia burgdorferi, or with complications related to such an infection.” It also defines clinical diagnosis as determined by a physician “…that is based on knowledge obtained through the medical history and physical examination alone, or in conjunction with the testing that provides supportive data for such clinical diagnosis.” In addition, it provides for updating the Lyme disease definition if other strains are found to cause Lyme disease.
The full press release is linked here. The complete text of the Act Concerning the Use of Long-Term Antibiotics for the Treatment of Lyme Disease, which will come into effect on July 1st, 2009, is linked here.
Another victory for the Lyme community. But let's keep the momentum building. CanLyme's president Jim Wilson has issued the following challenge:
I want to attach another copy of our 2008 letter to the Chief Public Medical Officer for Canada, Dr. David Butler-Jones. He seems to have been able to simply ignore this letter. Please let your MPs know that we demand action. Send them another copy of the letter. Do not let them off the hook here. With the passing of the law in Connecticut we demand to know on what basis our own health care system is refusing input from patients and protection for doctors. Don't be afraid to ask your MP for a response in writing as to what steps they intend to take to enforce the rights of Canadian patients, Canadian doctors and the Canadian Lyme Disease Foundation's medical experts to establish Lyme guidelines for Canada.
Please write your representatives today. MP and MPP contact info can be accessed conveniently through the Lyme Links to the right of this article. Together we are making a difference!
An excerpt from the Lyme Disease Association press release follows:
HB 6200 contains language that will protect CT licensed Lyme treating physicians from prosecution by the State of Connecticut Medical Examining Board solely on the basis of a clinical diagnosis and /or for treatment of long-term Lyme disease. The bill provides the definition for Lyme disease which includes “the presence in a patient of signs and symptoms compatible with acute infection with Borrelia burgdorferi; or with late stage or persistent or chronic infection with Borrelia burgdorferi, or with complications related to such an infection.” It also defines clinical diagnosis as determined by a physician “…that is based on knowledge obtained through the medical history and physical examination alone, or in conjunction with the testing that provides supportive data for such clinical diagnosis.” In addition, it provides for updating the Lyme disease definition if other strains are found to cause Lyme disease.
The full press release is linked here. The complete text of the Act Concerning the Use of Long-Term Antibiotics for the Treatment of Lyme Disease, which will come into effect on July 1st, 2009, is linked here.
Another victory for the Lyme community. But let's keep the momentum building. CanLyme's president Jim Wilson has issued the following challenge:
I want to attach another copy of our 2008 letter to the Chief Public Medical Officer for Canada, Dr. David Butler-Jones. He seems to have been able to simply ignore this letter. Please let your MPs know that we demand action. Send them another copy of the letter. Do not let them off the hook here. With the passing of the law in Connecticut we demand to know on what basis our own health care system is refusing input from patients and protection for doctors. Don't be afraid to ask your MP for a response in writing as to what steps they intend to take to enforce the rights of Canadian patients, Canadian doctors and the Canadian Lyme Disease Foundation's medical experts to establish Lyme guidelines for Canada.
Please write your representatives today. MP and MPP contact info can be accessed conveniently through the Lyme Links to the right of this article. Together we are making a difference!
Wednesday, May 20, 2009
Magnotta and CanLyme take to the airwaves
Controversial radio ads launched this month across Canada.Lyme disease is the fastest growing infectious disease in the world but the Canadian government won’t acknowledge this fact because it lacks proper understanding of the disease, continues to provide Canadians with poor testing methods and operates on the belief that the disease is rare in this country. That’s the root problem in fighting Lyme disease in Canada according to Magnotta Winery Corporation and the Canadian Lyme Disease Foundation (CanLyme) who have teamed up to challenge the government’s stance on this complex illness with a series of radio ads launching this month, the first of their kind in Canada.
So say Magnotta and CanLyme, and we would have to agree. The complete press release is linked here. If you haven't yet heard these ads on your local radio station, you can listen to the informative radio spots through these links:
Lyme Radio Ad #1
Lyme Radio Ad #2
Lyme Radio Ad #3
If you are not already aware, Magnotta has for a few years been bottling a delicious red wine (no bias here...) as a fund raiser for CanLyme's goal of establishing a Canadian Lyme disease research facility and clinic. A portion of the proceeds from the sale of this wine go to CanLyme for this purpose. Check out the Magnotta link in our Lyme Links in the right-hand column for more info.
Also, it is not long until the 4th Annual True North Golf Tournament (to be held at the Thornhill Golf and Country Club on June 1st 2009), another Magnotta event in support of CanLyme. To learn about this and other southern Ontario events planned for Lyme disease awareness month, visit Magnotta today.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
